Latest
What has been said since the Scheme landed
Coverage and statements on the eight-year rule, newest first. The most recent are here; the rest open below. Pick a kind, or a side: a piece is marked for or against the eight years when it argues one, in its own voice or through the people it is about.
- Irish citizenship reforms should address discrepancy affecting PhD studentsThe Irish Times Letter Against 8 years · Jovan Jeromela, Dublin 1: four years of a doctorate count as reckonable residence only on a Marie Curie grant or for EU citizens, so eight years means a 12-year path for PhD graduates. He backs a transition too.
- Letters to the editor on... Assessment of Need, citizenship rules and our new subscription serviceThe Journal Letter Against 8 years · Reno Chen, Dublin, here since January 2023 on a Stamp 4 from the Immigrant Investor Programme: when that programme closed, cases already in it went on. Eight years for future arrivals need not mean changing the rules halfway through.
- Rules on citizenship are not fair when you look at ease of access for BritishIrish Independent Letter Against 8 years · Eileen Keane, Derbyshire: people who work and pay taxes here would wait eight years, while someone in the UK who knows nothing about Ireland and has never visited, but has an Irish grandparent, gets citizenship within one year.
- Letters to the editor on... new citizenship rules, sinning against ecology and Dublin after darkThe Journal Letter Against 8 years · Dr Ayman Ghoneim, a transplant surgeon on a Critical Skills permit, four years in come October, asks for a transition: four kilometres into a 5km race, “the finish line has moved another three kilometres away.”
- Where’s the evidence that eight years’ residency produces better citizens than five?Irish Independent Letter Against 8 years · A reader who agrees citizenship should mean something, and accepts checks on character, means and integration, asks for the evidence that eight years makes better citizens than five.
- Government appearing tough on immigrationIrish Examiner Letter Against 8 years · Sarah Clarke, Enniscorthy: the five-year route already means paperwork, fees and character checks, and three more years for people who followed the rules only moves the goalposts.
- PBP v JOCThe Journal Letter For 8 years · Dylan Flanagan, Co Waterford: comparing Jim O’Callaghan to Farage and Trump is disingenuous. The rules, though “not entirely made in good faith”, help stop the rise of the far right by bringing Ireland in line with Europe.
- Citizenship change proposals are deeply short-sightedThe Irish Times Letter Against 8 years · Gill Kennedy on the nurses, doctors and engineers who spent five years saving for an application, and on a country with falling birth rates making itself harder to settle in.
- Citizenship rule changeIrish Examiner Letter · Barry Mahon, Sherkin Island: the new rules coincide exactly with the situation of many of the first refugees from Ukraine, who will in effect have three more years to wait before they can apply. “Interesting coincidence?”
- Law sends message of appeasementIrish Examiner Letter Against 8 years · Peter Elst, Donabate, months from applying with a Malaysian spouse and an Irish-born toddler: eight years puts Ireland at the restrictive end of the EU and sends “a message of appeasement”. He asks for a 12-month grace period or a phased rise.
- Moving the goalposts on citizenship rules is deeply unfairThe Irish Times Letter Against 8 years · A GP in Athenry on the overseas doctors who worked through Covid, and a reader who calls the retrospective reach an invitation to judicial review.
- Under new citizenship proposals, my 4.5 years in Ireland are being erasedThe Irish Times Letter Against 8 years · A reader four and a half years in: the years already served would count for nothing.
- Rules bend for those who did not obey them and tighten for those who didIrish Examiner Letter Against 8 years · Guilherme Daniel Gomes, Athlone, nearly four years into the five: eight years for newcomers should be a new deal they know in advance. He asks for a saving clause that keeps people already counting under the five-year rule on it.
- Goalposts have moved for immigrants already on the route to citizenshipIrish Independent Letter Against 8 years · A reader: raising the requirement from five years to eight would place an unfair and unnecessary burden on thousands of legal residents who have built their lives around the existing rule.
- New citizenship rules risk alienating people Ireland urgently needs to retainThe Irish Times Letter Against 8 years · The people the State spends most on recruiting are the ones the rule would push back three years.
- What problem is Jim O’Callaghan trying to solve with new hurdles to citizenship?The Irish Times Letter Against 8 years · Gerry Prizeman on an economy sustained by workers born elsewhere, and Gerald Flynn on a residence rule that was three years until last year.
- Language test for Irish citizenship raises questionsThe Irish Times Letter · Which language, at what level, marked by whom — none of it is answered by the Scheme.
- Language and citizenshipThe Irish Times Letter · Conor O’Carroll, Donnybrook, a migrant in four European countries for more than 12 years: all of them ask for A2 or B1 language and financial independence, and asking the same here is not anti-migrant.
- Language tests for new citizensThe Irish Times Letter · Bernie Cronin, Clondalkin: Ireland is the only EU country with no language test for new citizens, and if the Department’s proposals are in doubt, put them to a referendum, as citizenship was in 2004.
Who else
You are not the only one saying this.
Every organisation, party and piece of coverage we could find against the eight-year rule. The petitions have a page of their own. If you know of something missing, tell us.
Joint statementIrish Council for Civil LibertiesPublished the statement seven organisations signed on 7 September: no rationale, no research and no evidence has been presented for any of this.iccl.ie →
OrganisationImmigrant Council of IrelandFree legal advice and an information line on citizenship and permanency. Signed the joint statement.immigrantcouncil.ie →
OrganisationDorasLimerick-based migrant rights NGO, working nationally on integration and immigration policy. Signed the joint statement.doras.org →
OrganisationIrish Refugee CouncilRuns the information hub explaining the new asylum and citizenship laws as they land. Signed the joint statement.irishrefugeecouncil.ie →
OrganisationMigrant Rights Centre IrelandOrganises migrant workers and tracks citizenship policy and ceremony dates. Signed the joint statement.mrci.ie →
OrganisationNasc, the Migrant and Refugee Rights CentreCork-based, legal support and advocacy for migrants and refugees. Signed the joint statement.nascireland.org →
OrganisationAkiDwANational network of migrant women living in Ireland. Signed the joint statement.akidwa.ie →
PartyPeople Before ProfitCalls the changes a weaponisation of citizenship rules, with the mainstream right competing with the far right to inflame anti-immigrant opinion.pbp.ie →
PartySolidarityReads the bill as an attack on migrants, written to chase the far right rather than to fix anything in the system.solidarity.ie →
ExplainerIrish Citizenship Changes 2026: What’s Actually ProposedA plain, calm walk through what is in the Scheme and what is not, for people trying to work out whether it catches them.howtoireland.com →
CoverageIrish Legal NewsFollowing the Bill through drafting and scrutiny, and the lawyers and organisations raising objections to it.irishlegal.com →