#keepitfiveSay no to the citizenship overhaul

Latest

What has been said since the Scheme landed

Coverage and statements on the eight-year rule, newest first. The most recent are here; the rest open below. Pick a kind, or a side: a piece is marked for or against the eight years when it argues one, in its own voice or through the people it is about.

  1. Eight years should be bare minimum for the Irish passportGript Opinion For 8 years · Fatima Gunning. Eight years is a requirement most of Europe would consider unremarkable, she argues, and the media has answered it with what amount to sob stories about foreigners who want Irish passports.
  2. OPINION with Eddie Punch: It’s time to talk about citizenship?The Clare Champion Opinion For 8 years · Eddie Punch for eight years and the tests: five years is too soon to vote in referendums, he argues, citing about 236,000 naturalisations since 2011.
  3. Citizenship ApplicationsOireachtas · Dáil question Official For 8 years · Robert Troy asks whether residence already built up keeps the old rules; Eamon Scanlon asks to keep three years for spouses married before 2025. The answer: every reform needs a start date, and some people fall either side of it.
  4. Residency PermitsOireachtas · Dáil question Official For 8 years · Robert Troy asks for transitional provisions and the evidence for eight years. The answer: the five-year rule holds only until the Bill is enacted, and the aim is integration and public confidence. No evidence is given.
  5. Naturalisation ApplicationsOireachtas · Dáil question Official For 8 years · Seán Ó Fearghaíl passes on concerns sent to him. The answer: applications made after the law starts are judged under the new rules, and no profession, healthcare included, is set apart.
  6. General Scheme of the Irish Nationality and Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2026gov.ie Official For 8 years · The Department publishes the Scheme: two years’ continuous residence plus six of the previous ten, five years for spouses instead of three, language and civics tests, a minimum income the Minister sets, and no count for time on Temporary Protection.
  7. PBP v JOCThe Journal Letter For 8 years · Dylan Flanagan, Co Waterford: comparing Jim O’Callaghan to Farage and Trump is disingenuous. The rules, though “not entirely made in good faith”, help stop the rise of the far right by bringing Ireland in line with Europe.
  8. Eoin O’Malley: Stricter citizenship rules are common sense, not ‘performative cruelty’Irish Independent Opinion For 8 years · Eoin O’Malley. Stricter rules are common sense, not “performative cruelty”, he argues; the column opens in 1935, when the Irish government took control of citizenship after years of Free State passports issued in the name of King George V.
  9. Yes, we must stop handing out Irish citizenships like smartiesGript Opinion For 8 years · Niamh Uí Bhriain. Ireland granted 4.5 citizenships per 1,000 people in 2024 against an EU average of 2.4, she writes, and moving away from handing citizenship out “like smarties” is long overdue.
  10. Justice minister secures priority drafting of Irish Nationality and Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2026Irish Legal News News For 8 years · Jim O’Callaghan and Colm Brophy win priority drafting. Brophy: citizenship “is a privilege, not a right”. O’Callaghan asks that comparisons with other EU states “consider the entire framework”, residence, language and civic knowledge together.
  11. Government approval secured for the priority drafting of the Billgov.ie Official For 8 years · Cabinet clears the Bill for drafting and sends the Scheme to the justice committee. Target: enacted by Christmas.
  12. Irish Examiner view: Sensible citizenship rules could unite people rather than divide themIrish Examiner · Editorial Opinion For 8 years · The paper’s editorial: eight years, civics and a language test the Minister says will be relatively simple are the reasonable expectations any country might have of a new citizen, and a common language can bond people, as English has in the US.
  13. Citizenship a privilege, says minister ahead of overhaulRTÉ News For 8 years · Jim O’Callaghan makes the case before Cabinet: an earned privilege, not the passage of time.

Who else

You are not the only one saying this.

Every organisation, party and piece of coverage we could find against the eight-year rule. The petitions have a page of their own. If you know of something missing, tell us.

Eleven organisations, parties and outlets. Drag or scroll sideways.

Joint statementIrish Council for Civil LibertiesPublished the statement seven organisations signed on 7 September: no rationale, no research and no evidence has been presented for any of this.iccl.ie →OrganisationImmigrant Council of IrelandFree legal advice and an information line on citizenship and permanency. Signed the joint statement.immigrantcouncil.ie →OrganisationDorasLimerick-based migrant rights NGO, working nationally on integration and immigration policy. Signed the joint statement.doras.org →OrganisationIrish Refugee CouncilRuns the information hub explaining the new asylum and citizenship laws as they land. Signed the joint statement.irishrefugeecouncil.ie →OrganisationMigrant Rights Centre IrelandOrganises migrant workers and tracks citizenship policy and ceremony dates. Signed the joint statement.mrci.ie →OrganisationNasc, the Migrant and Refugee Rights CentreCork-based, legal support and advocacy for migrants and refugees. Signed the joint statement.nascireland.org →OrganisationAkiDwANational network of migrant women living in Ireland. Signed the joint statement.akidwa.ie →PartyPeople Before ProfitCalls the changes a weaponisation of citizenship rules, with the mainstream right competing with the far right to inflame anti-immigrant opinion.pbp.ie →PartySolidarityReads the bill as an attack on migrants, written to chase the far right rather than to fix anything in the system.solidarity.ie →ExplainerIrish Citizenship Changes 2026: What’s Actually ProposedA plain, calm walk through what is in the Scheme and what is not, for people trying to work out whether it catches them.howtoireland.com →CoverageIrish Legal NewsFollowing the Bill through drafting and scrutiny, and the lawyers and organisations raising objections to it.irishlegal.com →

Not legal advice. The Bill itself has not been drafted. The General Scheme was published on 21 September 2026 and is here as a PDF, and summarised Head by Head on The Bill; anyone assessing their own position should read it and take advice on their own dates and permissions.

Compiled 10 September 2026 from published sources. Last updated . Plain-text version, every figure with its source: /facts.php.